10 Best SEO Agencies in Cleveland in 2024

Is your website struggling to reach potential customers in Cleveland? Many businesses find themselves lost in the lower pages of search engine results, unable to connect with people actively looking for their products or services. This is where SEO agencies can make a significant difference.

SEO agencies specialize in improving your website's visibility on search engines like Google. They use various techniques to help your site rank higher for relevant keywords, making it easier for customers to find you. These strategies include optimizing your website's content, improving its technical structure, building quality backlinks, and enhancing your local search presence. By working with an experienced SEO agency, Cleveland businesses can attract more qualified leads and grow their customer base.

This article highlights Cleveland's 10 best SEO agencies, each offering unique strengths to help your business excel online. Whether you're a small local business or a large corporation, these agencies have the expertise to boost your digital presence and drive meaningful results for your company.

Our top picks

Top 5

1. Sure Oak. - Best SEO agency overall

2. Rollmatics. - Best for customer-centric marketing

3. Protea Digital. - Best for startups and entrepreneurs

4. The Bartoli Consulting Group. - Best for small to mid-size B2B organizations

5. eMojo Digital Marketing. - Best for comprehensive digital marketing solutions

Brief overview

Sure Oak, a reputable SEO agency, empowers businesses to dominate their online presence through innovative strategies and unrivaled industry knowledge. Their dedicated team of specialists employs cutting-edge tactics to propel clients to the top of search engine rankings, fostering substantial growth and success. By optimizing websites and generating high-quality leads, Sure Oak consistently delivers measurable results that transform digital marketing outcomes for enterprises of all scales.

Why we chose Sure Oak

Sure Oak stands out from other SEO agencies with its comprehensive approach, encompassing services from content optimization to premium link building. The agency's unparalleled SEO expertise and proprietary growth strategies ensure that businesses achieve higher rankings and faster growth. By continuously refining and expanding its holistic approach, Sure Oak consistently delivers the visibility clients need to boost conversions.

• Budget: $200 - $100k

• Track record: 51% increase in demo signups for a B2B SaaS client; 50% increase in website traffic for an AI/ML software client; 4x increase in year-over-year conversion rates using Leadoo bots

• Industry focus: Education, finance, electronics, health& wellness, travel, professional services

Brief overview

Rollmatics is a digital marketing agency established by a group of former Google professionals dedicated to empowering businesses in their online endeavors. With a collective experience exceeding 25 years, the Rollmatics team specializes in strategic consulting, website optimization, and social media management. Their unique advantage stems from deep industry insights and a comprehensive grasp of marketing strategies, positioning Rollmatics to redefine how businesses engage with online growth and marketing.

Why we chose Rollmatics

Rollmatics is an excellent choice for SEO services, distinguished by its impressive success record and specialized industry knowledge. Founded by former Google employees, the agency utilizes their in-depth understanding of search engine algorithms to develop data-driven SEO strategies that yield tangible results. In addition to traditional SEO, Rollmatics excels in social media management, effectively boosting brand engagement and driving conversions through organic efforts. Their blend of extensive expertise, practical experience, and commitment to achieving meaningful business outcomes makes Rollmatics a strong partner for companies aiming to enhance their online visibility and growth.

• Budget: $500 - $100k

• Track record: Ability to achieve significant improvements in conversions, up to 20%, through strategic website enhancements and ROI-based campaigns.

• Industry focus: Food & drink, health & wellness, art & entertainment, technology

Brief overview

Protea Digital is a well-established digital marketing agency with over 11 years of experience in delivering effective SEO solutions. Catering to both B2C and B2B sectors such as software, finance, education, and e-commerce, the agency has developed a strong proficiency across various industries. Committed to ethics, sustainability, and open communication, Protea Digital fosters long-term partnerships with clients while excelling in market analysis and opportunity identification.

Why we chose Protea Digital

Protea Digital's methodical approach to market analysis and business growth has resulted in significant achievements, showcasing their talent for identifying opportunities and positioning clients at the forefront of their industries. Their partnership with the startup Thomas Lee exemplifies their capability to effectively lower costs per acquisition through refined digital paid media strategies. These accomplishments reflect Protea Digital's dedication to producing meaningful results for their clients.

• Budget: Up to $100k

• Track record: They have helped clients achieve impressive results, such as: Reducing cost per acquisition (CPA) by over 66% to $25 per sale; generating leads and test accounts at scale while decreasing cost per lead; finding and expanding to 20+ new markets for a client

• Industry focus: Education, health & wellness, professional services, nonprofit & government, electronics

Brief overview

Bartoli Consulting Group is a specialized search marketing firm that provides tailored digital marketing assessments and SEO services for B2B enterprises. With a focus on creating comprehensive search engine optimization strategies and developing complete SEO programs, the company aims to empower businesses to achieve sustainable growth and enhance their online presence. Their team of professionals is dedicated to improving clients' online reputations and return on investment, earning accolades for their effective communication and transparent processes.

Why we chose Bartoli Consulting Group

Bartoli Consulting Group distinguishes itself through its specialized knowledge in assisting small to mid-sized B2B organizations in achieving growth via targeted marketing strategies. Founded by software entrepreneur Janet Bartoli, the firm brings a profound understanding of the specific challenges that property management companies and similar businesses encounter. A standout feature of their service is the provision of a dedicated Chief Marketing Officer (CMO), who offers expert guidance in developing and enhancing digital marketing initiatives. This level of support enables clients to adopt advanced marketing techniques and technologies, driving tangible results, as reflected in the positive feedback and success stories from their diverse clientele.

• Budget: $200 - $100k

• Track record: Over 16 years of deep specialization in designing multi-national & enterprise SEO strategies and end-to-end SEO program development.

• Industry focus: Professional services, sports, outdoors & fitness, home & garden, education, technology

Brief overview

eMojo Digital Solutions excels in developing effective and scalable strategies aimed at fostering business growth. Committed to achieving measurable outcomes, the agency prioritizes key areas including SEO, paid advertising, conversion rate optimization (CRO), and automation. By consistently monitoring data and performance metrics, eMojo ensures that clients receive a transparent return on investment.

Why we chose eMojo Digital Marketing

eMojo Digital Solutions distinguished itself through its holistic approach to fostering business growth with a focus on SEO, paid advertising, conversion rate optimization (CRO), and automation. Its commitment to developing efficient and scalable strategies, along with a strong emphasis on data tracking to ensure a transparent return on investment, made it a compelling option. The agency's proven success is reflected in its collaborations with clients such as Nili Lotan, a luxury fashion brand recognized in leading publications and embraced by a loyal celebrity clientele.

• Budget: $200 - $1M+

• Track record: eMojo achieved 300% increase in leads for Ravello, drove 50% higher conversion rates for clients, and delivered 40% boost in sales for customers.

• Industry focus: Finance, professional service, real estate, social & community, sports, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, technology, travel

Brief overview

Zonder Marketing is a digital marketing agency directed by a seasoned expert in performance and growth. The agency focuses on developing comprehensive marketing strategies that integrate SEM, Paid Social, and SEO to effectively engage businesses with their target audiences. By employing detailed data analysis and a strong grasp of key performance indicators (KPIs), Zonder Marketing provides customized solutions that yield significant, measurable outcomes.

Why we chose Zonder Marketing

Zonder Marketing was selected for its exceptional expertise and consistent record of driving growth across diverse digital marketing channels. The agency's strategic approach, informed by meticulous data analysis and a comprehensive understanding of KPIs, ensures that marketing initiatives are both effective and profitable. With a history of notable successes and a reputation for delivering exceptional results, Zonder Marketing is a standout choice for businesses seeking substantial growth and marketing efficiency.

• Budget: $200 - $1M+

• Track record: Increased profit of CarParts.com account by 94% YoY while maintaining 15% revenue growth; grew Field Notes revenue by 40%+ YoY through channel expansion and optimization; launched new channels for kidpik, resulting in 3x revenue increase to reinvest in growth

• Industry focus: Electronics, professional services, health & wellness, style & fashion, social & community, technology

Brief overview

BCC Interactive, established in 2009 in New York City, is a distinguished digital marketing agency that focuses on advanced search engine optimization (SEO) services. Their experienced team collaborates with clients to develop customized strategies aimed at improving online presence, increasing web traffic, and meeting specific business goals. With a commitment to staying updated on SEO advancements, BCC Interactive effectively fosters enduring growth through a combination of technical enhancements, content creation, and link-building strategies.

Why we chose BCC Interactive

BCC Interactive's strong history of achieving measurable results for clients in diverse sectors is one of the main contributing factors to us choosing them. Their portfolio highlights a capacity for driving growth through customized SEO strategies and comprehensive digital marketing solutions. Notably, BCC Interactive has successfully increased organic traffic for clients, leading to significant revenue enhancements.

• Budget: $5k - $20k

• Track record: One client experienced a dramatic 1,800% increase in organic traffic after BCC Interactive revamped their website and implemented a comprehensive local SEO strategy.

• Industry focus: Professional services, technology, sports, outdoors & fitness, health & wellness, art & entertainment

Brief overview

LanternSol is an established digital marketing agency with more than ten years of expertise in e-commerce. Having generated over $100 million in online sales and created over 500 tailored websites and applications, the agency offers a comprehensive range of services, including SEO, PPC, CRO, web development, and social media advertising. With a proven track record of delivering impressive returns on investment—averaging 3-12x ROAs for ad campaigns—LanternSol is recognized for its impactful SEO strategies that enhance keyword rankings on Google, driving significant increases in organic traffic and conversions.

Why we chose Lantern Sol

LanternSol distinguishes itself through its extensive experience and deep expertise in e-commerce and digital marketing. With over a decade of service, the agency has successfully supported numerous businesses in achieving remarkable online sales and creating tailored websites and applications. Its strong SEO capabilities are reflected in the significant number of keywords ranked on Google's first page, and the agency's campaigns are known for delivering impressive returns.

• Budget: $5k - $500k

• Track record: LanternSol helped a client generate a 5.86 ROAS and scaled their top-line revenue to seven figures in less than four months, even amidst iOS 14.5 challenges.

• Industry focus: Sports, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, beauty, food & drink, real estate, finance, home & garden, health & wellness

Brief overview

Conversion Media is a content marketing agency focused on delivering exceptional SEO services. Committed to a meticulous approach and active implementation, the agency excels in expanding brands' content potential. Its expertise lies in personalized link-building strategies, comprehensive strategic insights, and the capability to navigate intricate topics effectively.

Why we chose Conversion Media

Conversion Media distinguishes itself from other agencies through its innovative SEO and content marketing approach. By prioritizing direct connections with readers, the agency enhances conversion potential. Their proficiency in crafting compelling content and effective link-building strategies has driven notable client success. This capability to design and implement impactful content marketing strategies positions Conversion Media as a trusted ally for businesses aiming to enhance their online visibility.

• Budget: Up to $100k

• Track record: Organic revenue increased by 26.8% over 12 months; average traffic levels were 47.4% higher than before; organic visitors grew to 1.7 million per month, a 287% increase.

• Industry focus: Technology, professional services, education, style & fashion, home & garden, art & entertainment

Brief overview

Blue Tuskr is a comprehensive digital marketing agency specializing in SEO services designed for e-commerce sellers seeking growth. With a proven history of executing effective marketing strategies, the company has successfully enhanced lead quality, revenue, and brand visibility for its clients. By concentrating on organic and paid social media, search advertising, email marketing, and website optimization, Blue Tuskr effectively drives traffic and boosts conversion rates. Its customized strategies have enabled businesses such as Onfloor, Styku, and Good Idea to achieve significant market expansion.

Why we chose BlueTuskr

Blue Tuskr distinguishes itself with its expertise in fostering organic growth through effective SEO, optimizing social media engagement, and enhancing brand visibility. This makes it an excellent option for businesses aiming to boost growth and strengthen their market presence. Additionally, Blue Tuskr has a proven track record with brands such as Beautyguarde, Axe & Sledge, and Ironyun, where its skill in targeted advertising and strategic marketing has led to notable revenue growth and enhanced return on investment.

• Budget: $2k - $200k

• Track record: Tailored marketing strategies have led to impressive outcomes, such as a 760% increase in quality leads for Onfloor, a 115% revenue increase for Styku, and a 120% revenue growth for Lifelong Collectibles.

• Industry focus: Art & entertainment, automotive, baby, beauty, electronics, food & drink, health & wellness, home & garden, pets, professional services, sports, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, technology

Do I need to hire an SEO agency?

Are you struggling to drive organic traffic to your website and boost your online visibility? If so, it may be time to consider hiring an SEO agency. Search engine optimization (SEO) is a complex and ever-evolving field, and keeping up with the latest trends and best practices can be a full-time job.

An SEO agency can provide a team of experienced professionals who are dedicated to improving your website's search engine rankings and driving more qualified leads to your business. They have access to advanced tools and data that can help them identify opportunities for improvement and develop a customized strategy to achieve your goals.

Hiring an SEO agency can be particularly beneficial for businesses that lack in-house expertise or resources to dedicate to SEO. By outsourcing this critical function, you can free up your team to focus on other aspects of your business while still ensuring that your online presence is optimized for success.

However, it's important to do your due diligence when selecting an SEO agency. Look for a provider with a proven track record of delivering results, a deep understanding of your industry, and a commitment to ethical and transparent practices.

By partnering with the right SEO agency, you can unlock the full potential of your online presence and drive sustainable growth for your business. Whether you're looking to increase brand awareness, generate more leads, or boost your e-commerce sales, an experienced SEO team can help you achieve your objectives.

What does an SEO agency do?

An SEO agency is responsible for a wide range of tasks to improve a client's online visibility and search engine rankings. Here are some of the key responsibilities of an SEO agency:

Keyword Research and Strategy

SEO agencies conduct in-depth keyword research to identify the most relevant and high-performing keywords for a client's business . They develop a targeted keyword strategy that aligns with the client's business goals and the intent of their target audience.

Content Optimization

SEO agencies optimize website content, including blog posts, product pages, and meta tags, to improve search engine rankings . They ensure content is engaging, informative, and optimized for users and search engines.

Technical SEO

SEO agencies perform comprehensive website audits to identify and address any technical issues hindering search engine crawling and indexing . They optimize website structure, speed, and other technical elements to enhance the site's overall search engine performance.

Link Building and Off-Page Optimization

SEO agencies develop and execute link-building strategies to acquire high-quality, relevant backlinks from authoritative websites . They also focus on other off-page optimization tactics, such as social media marketing and directory listings, to improve the site's overall authority and visibility.

Reporting and Analytics

SEO agencies provide regular reports and analytics to track the progress and effectiveness of their strategies. They use data-driven insights to continuously refine and optimize their approach, ensuring that clients see tangible results.

By partnering with an experienced SEO agency, businesses can leverage their expertise and resources to improve their online presence, drive more targeted traffic, and ultimately achieve their marketing and business goals.

How to choose the best SEO agency for your business

• Define your SEO goals: Start by clearly outlining your business objectives and the specific SEO outcomes you want to achieve, such as improving search rankings, increasing website traffic, or boosting conversions. This will help you find an agency that can deliver the services you need.
• Evaluate the agency's expertise: Look for an SEO agency with a proven track record of success, relevant industry experience, and a diverse team of specialists in areas like technical SEO, content creation, and link building. Review their case studies, client testimonials, and industry awards to assess their capabilities.
• Assess the agency's transparency: A reputable SEO agency should be upfront about their processes, strategies, and reporting methods. Ask them to explain their approach in detail and ensure they are committed to using ethical, white-hat techniques that align with search engine guidelines.
• Consider the agency's communication and collaboration: Choose an SEO agency that is responsive, transparent, and willing to collaborate closely with your team. Assess their communication style and ensure they are a good cultural fit for your organization.
• Understand the agency's pricing and contract terms: Evaluate the agency's pricing structure, including any hidden fees or long-term commitments. Ensure the contract terms are clear and align with your budget and expectations.
• Prioritize ongoing reporting and optimization: Look for an SEO agency that provides regular performance reports, analyzes the results, and continuously optimizes your strategy based on data-driven insights. This will help you track progress and make informed decisions.

Hire an SEO agency with data-backed results

Finding the right SEO agency can be tiresome, and that's where Mayple steps in, offering a smart solution by connecting you with proven SEO agencies. Their dedication to improving your ranking and increasing your traffic lands them the title of top SEO agency with us. 

Sure Oak is the go-to agency for businesses looking to dominate search engine rankings and generate high-quality leads. For data-driven SEO strategies and social media management from former Google employees, Rollmatics offers specialized expertise. And if you need a full-service digital agency with a strong focus on ROI measurement across various industries, Protea Digital has you covered.

None of the above seems like the right fit? Not to worry. With Mayple you’ll find the perfect match for your business needs by harnessing the power of AI. Just because someone’s a marketing expert, doesn’t mean they’re right for your brand. Our AI algorithm uses multiple data sources and matching factors to ensure the experts you work with are the perfect fit to help you grow and scale. Exponential business growth is just one call away!