10 Best SEO Agencies In Columbus In 2024

Finding your business among many competitors out there can take time and effort. SEO agencies in Columbus help by using search engine optimization to improve your online presence and connect you better with your target audience.

If you’re a business owner or blogger, the challenge is not just being online; it's about being visible to the right people at the right time. SEO agencies in Columbus focus on enhancing your website's visibility in search results, which leads to more traffic and potential customers. If you're thinking about increasing your website's reach or refining your online strategy, knowing what digital marketing agencies do is essential for staying relevant in the digital world.

Our top picks

Top 5

1. Lantern Sol - Best SEO agency overall.

2. Conversion Media - Best for e-learning companies.

3. BCC Interactive - Best for customized SEO strategies.

4. BlueTuskr - Best for driving organic growth.

5. eMojo Digital Marketing - Best for scalable digital marketing.

Brief overview

Lantern Sol is a seasoned digital marketing agency specializing in eCommerce with over a decade of experience. It has facilitated over $100 million in online sales and developed over 500 custom websites and applications. Services encompass SEO, PPC, CRO, web development, and social media advertising. The company has demonstrated significant ROI for clients, with ad campaigns yielding ROAs of 3-12x on average. Known for its effective SEO strategies, Lantern Sol helps businesses rank thousands of keywords on Google, achieving substantial growth in organic traffic and conversions. Over 600 companies trust them, and Shopify and Amazon have featured them.

Why we chose Lantern Sol

Lantern Sol stands out due to its track record and expertise in eCommerce and digital marketing. With over a decade of experience, it has helped companies achieve over $100 million in online sales and developed more than 500 custom websites and apps. The company’s SEO proficiency is evident with thousands of keywords ranked on Google's homepage, and its campaigns consistently achieve high ROAs, sometimes reaching up to 32x.

• Budget: $5000 - $500k

• Track record: Lantern Sol helped a client generate a 5.86 ROAS and scaled their top-line revenue to seven figures in less than four months, even amidst iOS 14.5 challenges.

• Industry focus: Sports, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, beauty, food & drink, real estate, finance, home & garden, health & wellness

Brief overview

Conversion Media is a content marketing agency that specializes in SEO services. It prides itself on its detailed approach, hands-on implementation, and ability to push the boundaries of what content can do for a brand. Its strengths include a personal approach to link-building, deep strategy knowledge, and the ability to tackle complex subjects.

Why we chose Conversion Media

Conversion Media stands out from other agencies due to its unique SEO and content marketing approach. They focus on building direct relationships with readers, which is critical for conversion. Their expertise in creating engaging content and leveraging link-building strategies has led to significant success for their clients. For example, they helped Pew Pew Tactical increase organic revenue by 26.8% over 12 months, resulting in a six-figure revenue increase. The company’s ability to develop and execute effective content marketing plans has made it a valuable partner for businesses looking to improve their online presence.

• Budget: Up to $100k

• Track record: Notable achievements, including a 287% increase in traffic and an extra $440,000 monthly traffic value for Pew Pew Tactical.

• Industry focus: Technology, professional services, education, style & fashion, home & garden, art & entertainment

Brief overview

BCC Interactive, a prominent digital marketing agency based in New York City since 2009, specializes in providing top-tier search engine optimization (SEO) services. Their seasoned team of SEO experts collaborates closely with clients to craft tailored strategies that enhance online visibility, drive traffic, and align with specific business objectives. Known for staying at the forefront of SEO trends, BCC Interactive excels in delivering sustainable growth through technical optimizations, content development, and link-building tactics.

Why we chose BCC Interactive

BCC Interactive's impressive track record and proven success in delivering measurable results for clients across various industries were vital factors in our decision to partner with them. Its case studies showcase its ability to drive significant growth through tailored SEO strategies and integrated digital marketing solutions. For example, BCC Interactive managed to drive a 358% increase in organic traffic for a leading cannabis brand. This strategic effort resulted in a substantial revenue increase, reportedly contributing to $90 million.

• Budget: $5k - $20k

• Track record: One client experienced a dramatic 1,800% increase in organic traffic after BCC Interactive revamped their website and implemented a comprehensive local SEO strategy.

• Industry focus: Professional services, technology, sports, outdoors & fitness, health & wellness, art & entertainment

Brief overview

Blue Tuskr is a full-service digital marketing company that provides SEO services for eCommerce sellers to boost their growth. It has a track record of implementing successful marketing strategies that have significantly increased quality leads, revenue, and brand awareness for its clients. Blue Tuskr focuses on organic and paid social media, search ads, email marketing, and website optimization to drive traffic and enhance conversions. Its tailored approaches have helped businesses like Onfloor, Styku, and Good Idea substantially grow in their respective markets.

Why we chose Blue Tuskr

Blue Tuskr stands out for its ability to drive organic growth through SEO efforts, optimize social media presence, and enhance brand awareness. This has set it apart as a top choice for businesses looking to accelerate growth and solidify their market position. Moreover, Blue Tuskr's success stories extend to brands like Beautyguarde, Axe & Sledge, and Ironyun, where their expertise in highly targeted ad campaigns and strategic marketing planning has resulted in significant revenue increases and improved ROI.

• Budget: $2k - $200k

• Track record: Tailored marketing strategies have led to impressive outcomes, such as a 760% increase in quality leads for Onfloor, a 115% revenue increase for Styku, and a 120% revenue growth for Lifelong Collectibles.

• Industry focus: Art & entertainment, automotive, baby, beauty, electronics, food & drink, health & wellness, home & garden, pets, professional services, sprots, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, technology

Brief overview

eMojo Digital Solutions specializes in crafting efficient and scalable strategies to drive business growth. Dedicated to delivering measurable results, the agency focuses on critical areas such as SEO, Paid Channels, Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO), and Automation. eMojo's approach is centered around consistently tracking data and performance metrics to demonstrate a clear return on investment for its clients.

Why we chose eMojo Digital Solutions

eMojo Digital Solutions stood out for its comprehensive approach to driving business growth through SEO, Paid Channels, CRO, and Automation. Its dedication to crafting efficient and scalable strategies, combined with a focus on consistently tracking data to demonstrate a clear return on investment, made it an attractive choice. eMojo's track record of success is evident in its work with clients like Nili Lotan, a luxury fashion brand whose collections have been featured in top publications and accumulated a dedicated celebrity following.

• Budget: $200 - $1M+

• Track record: Lowered Zooz's MQL cost by roughly 50% and doubled the number of MQLs generated while also creating a beautiful new website that adheres to the brand's new guidelines.

• Industry focus: Finance, professional service, real estate, social & community, sports, outdoors & fitness, style & fashion, technology, travel

Brief overview

Zonder Marketing is a digital marketing agency led by a performance and growth expert with extensive experience in the industry. The agency specializes in crafting multi-channel marketing strategies that leverage SEM, Paid Social, and SEO to connect businesses with their ideal customers. Through meticulous data analysis and a deep understanding of key performance indicators (KPIs), Zonder Marketing delivers tailored solutions that drive measurable results.

Why we chose Zonder Marketing

We chose Zonder Marketing for its unparalleled expertise and proven track record in driving growth across multiple digital marketing channels. Its strategic approach, rooted in deep data analysis and a thorough understanding of KPIs, ensures that marketing efforts are effective and highly profitable. With notable successes and a history of delivering outstanding results, Zonder Marketing stands out as a top choice for businesses looking to achieve substantial growth and efficiency in their marketing efforts.

• Budget: $200 - $1M+

• Track record: Work with Kidpik led to a threefold increase in revenue through the revamp of Google Ads and Shopping feeds.

• Industry focus: Electronics, professional services, health & wellness, style & fashion, social & community, technology

Brief overview

WO Strategies is a digital marketing agency founded by Katherine Watier Ong, an experienced professional with over 25 years of expertise in running successful campaigns. The company has worked with various clients, including federal agencies, foreign governments, startups, nonprofits, and Fortune 500 companies, and is focused on G2C, B2B, and B2C audiences. WO Strategies specializes in organic traffic marketing and training for science-based organizations. It collaborates with clients to ensure they have the necessary skills and strategy to grow their organic traffic and get scientific answers into the hands of their customers.

Why we chose WO Strategies

WO Strategies stands out from other digital marketing agencies due to its unique focus on science-based organizations. Its campaigns have had a significant impact, such as helping the Environmental Working Group (EWG) handle a surge in traffic of 1.2 million visits in just four days. WO Strategies' expertise lies in understanding data and target customers, which is reflected in its SEO approach. It believes that solid marketing plans are based on these two critical understandings. It works closely with clients to ensure they have the skills and strategy to grow their organic traffic. This approach has led to notable successes, such as helping HealthIT.gov pivot search query volume toward electronic health records and Cancer.gov grow its traffic significantly.

• Budget: Up to $100k

• Track record: Assisted the National Cancer Institute (NCI) in increasing its clinical trial-related keywords by 79%.

• Industry focus: Automotive, food & drink, health & wellness, nonprofit & government, professional services, social & community, travel

Brief overview

Moburst's team believes that the combination of creative thinking, advanced technology, and data-driven insights is the key to solving clients' toughest mobile challenges. The agency's experts work tirelessly to connect brands with highly targeted audiences that convert into loyal users. Moburst offers a wide range of services to help businesses succeed in the digital landscape. These include mobile app marketing, search engine optimization (SEO), social media marketing, and performance advertising. The agency's data-driven approach and cutting-edge technology enable it to deliver measurable results for its clients.

Why we chose Moburst

Moburst's proven track record of success and innovative approach to digital marketing make it a standout choice for businesses looking to grow their mobile presence. Moburst's strategic and data-driven approach has also led to significant cost savings for their clients, including a 60% reduction in cost per install and an 87% decrease in Cost Per Install (CPI). What sets Moburst apart is its commitment to staying ahead of the curve by leveraging the latest technologies and best practices. The agency's expertise in areas such as App Store Optimization (ASO), Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO), and creative content creation has helped it achieve top 10 rankings in app stores for its clients over 225 times.

• Budget: $20k - $100k

• Track record: Helped numerous clients achieve impressive results, such as helping Samsung grow social downloads by 1400% and increasing Discovery Network's conversion ratio by 27%.

• Industry focus: Electronics, food & drink, finance, art & entertainment, professional services, automotive, education, health & wellness, home & garden, travel, nonprofit & government, style & fashion

Brief overview

Rollmatics is a digital marketing agency founded by a team of ex-Googlers passionate about helping businesses succeed online. With over 25 years of combined experience, the Rollmatics team offers strategic consulting, website optimization, and social media management services. The company’s competitive edge lies in its extensive industry knowledge and insider understanding of digital marketing dynamics. Rollmatics aims to transform how businesses approach online growth and marketing by revolutionizing traditional approaches.

Why we chose Rollmatics

Rollmatics stands out as a top choice for SEO services due to its track record of success and unique industry expertise. It leverages its insider understanding of search engine algorithms and marketing strategies to craft data-driven SEO plans that deliver measurable results. Moreover, Rollmatics' expertise extends beyond traditional SEO services to encompass social media management, where they have demonstrated remarkable growth in brand followings and a 10% increase in conversions through organic social efforts. Its industry knowledge, hands-on experience with Google's inner workings, and focus on delivering accurate business results make Rollmatics a compelling choice.

• Budget: $500 - $100k

• Track record: Ability to achieve significant improvements in conversions, up to 20%, through strategic website enhancements and ROI-based campaigns.

• Industry focus: Food & drink, health & wellness, art & entertainment, technology

Brief overview

Someone Rad LLC is a Cedar Rapids-based digital marketing agency specializing in email marketing, marketing automation, and campaign management. With extensive experience in creative performance marketing, they help businesses build and maintain strong customer relationships through owned media strategies. Their services are designed to enhance customer engagement and increase revenue by leveraging behavior-triggered emails and personalized marketing tactics. The agency focuses on developing long-term customer relationships by using data-driven insights to create targeted campaigns. They help businesses turn interactions into sales, ensuring sustainable growth and customer retention.

Why we chose Someone Rad LLC

We chose Someone Rad LLC for its innovative email marketing approach and ability to foster genuine customer relationships. Their focus on owned media strategies allows businesses to build sustainable engagement without relying solely on paid media. A notable success story involves Poppy's Chocolate, which saw significant revenue growth after implementing Someone Rad's strategies. The company's efforts helped Poppy's Chocolate avoid closure, generating over a million dollars in revenue each year for the following two years. This track record of transforming client outcomes makes Someone Rad a top choice.

• Budget: $200 - $200k

• Track record: Increases revenue growth to generate millions of dollars year over year, helping revive failing companies

• Industry focus: Art and entertainment, automotive, baby, beauty, electronics, education, finance, food and drink, gaming, health and wellness, home and garden, nonprofit and government, pets, professional services, real estate, social and community, sports, outdoors and fitness, style and fashion, technology, travel

Do I need to hire an SEO agency?

If you're considering hiring an SEO agency, assess your needs, budget, and goals. SEO professionals specialize in improving your website's ranking on search engines like Google. This means more people can find your website when they search for topics related to what you offer.

Hiring an SEO agency can be helpful if you have a business or blog and want to increase your online visibility and attract more visitors or customers. Agencies have the expertise to optimize your website and can handle this task while you focus on other parts of your business. If you're starting with a limited budget, you might want to learn basic SEO techniques before investing in professional services.

What does an SEO agency do?

SEO agencies can help improve the visibility of your website on search engines like Google. Here’s a breakdown of the main tasks they typically handle:

Keyword Research

Experts, like local SEO agencies, find people's words and phrases when searching for products or services in your area. They use these keywords to help your content appear more often in search results.

Content Creation

Professionals can create or modify your website's content to make it appealing to search engines. This involves using the right keywords and providing helpful information that matches people's needs.

On-Page Optimization

This includes making technical adjustments to your website, like improving your pages' structure and ensuring they load quickly. These changes help search engines understand your site better and can improve your rankings.

Link Building

Agency experts work to get other websites to link back to yours. Search engines view these links as votes of confidence, which can boost your site's ranking.

Analytics and Reporting

They track your website's performance regarding search rankings, traffic, and other key metrics. This information is used to refine strategies and show you the results of their work.

How to choose the best SEO agency for your business

Here are several vital steps to consider when choosing the right SEO specialists for your business:

• Define your goals: Before looking for an agency, know what you want to achieve with SEO. Do you want to increase sales, get more traffic, or improve your rankings for specific keywords? Clear goals will help you find an agency to meet your particular needs.
• Experience: Choose an agency that has experience in your industry. They'll understand your market and what your customers are looking for, which can lead to better SEO strategies.
• Track record: Look at the agency's results for other clients. Good indicators of success include case studies, testimonials, and client references. Don’t hesitate to ask for them.
• Understand their strategy: Ask potential digital marketing agencies about their approach to SEO. They should be able to explain their methods and how they plan to use them to help your business. Be wary of agencies that promise instant results, as SEO typically takes time.
• Budget: Make sure the professional services fit your budget. SEO costs vary, so finding an agency that offers what you need without overcharging is essential.
• Communication and reporting: Choose experts that communicate clearly and regularly. You should know what they're doing and how your site is performing. Regular reports and updates are crucial.

Hire an SEO agency with data-backed results

Finding the right SEO agency can be tiresome, and that's where Mayple steps in, offering a smart solution by connecting you with proven SEO professionals. Their dedication to improving your visibility and increasing your revenue has earned them the title of best SEO agency with us. 

Lantern Sol is an expert digital marketing agency focusing on eCommerce, boosting over $100 million in online sales with their effective SEO, PPC, CRO, and more. Conversion Media, specializing in SEO through content marketing, excels in detailed strategies and innovative link-building. For comprehensive and cutting-edge SEO services designed to enhance visibility and drive traffic, BCC Interactive from New York City has been a leading choice since 2009.

None of the above seems like the right fit? Not to worry. With Mayple can find the perfect match for your business needs by harnessing the power of AI. Just because someone’s a marketing expert doesn’t mean they’re right for your brand. Our AI algorithm uses multiple data sources and matching factors to ensure the experts you work with are the perfect fit to help you grow and scale. Exponential business growth is just one call away!