eCommerce Platform VS Marketplace: Which one?

By 2027, 59% of all online sales will be attributed to third-party marketplaces. In theory, that should tell you marketplaces are the place to be at, whether you're an eCommerce developer or a store owner.

Things are, as always, a bit more complex. On both ends of the stick (platforms/ marketplaces vs. sellers), the two options present both opportunities and challenges. So, what should you choose: a traditional eCommerce platform or hopping on the marketplace train?

We asked our vetted eCommerce agencies to give their views on the matter. Here's what we've learned.

Hire eCommerce agencies with a proven record

Work with top eCommerce agencies

Find the best eCommerce agency with proven experience and a successful track record to optimize your eCommerce business.

Find your expert



ECommerce platform vs marketplace: the basics

As the digital economy continues to grow, businesses and entrepreneurs are increasingly facing a critical decision: should they operate as an eCommerce platform or as a marketplace? While these two models might seem similar at first glance, they operate differently and serve distinct purposes. In this article, we’ll explore what eCommerce platforms and marketplaces are, their unique characteristics, and the advantages of each. We’ll also dive into their similarities and differences to help you determine the right model for your business.

What is an eCommerce operation?

An eCommerce operation revolves around a platform where businesses sell their own products or services directly to consumers. Think of a traditional online store where the owner is in charge of the goods or services provided. Popular examples include Shopify-powered websites, Nike's online store, or small businesses managing their own standalone platforms.

The key characteristics of an eCommerce platform include:

• Ownership: The business owns the inventory and is responsible for sales, operations, and fulfillment.

• Brand control: The platform is dedicated to the seller’s brand, enabling full control over how the products are presented.

• Customization: eCommerce stores allow the seller to personalize every aspect of their website, from the design to the user experience.

• Direct customer relationships: Businesses interact directly with consumers, maintaining a direct relationship through the sales and post-purchase process.

An eCommerce platform is ideal for businesses that want to focus on promoting their own brand and products, while maintaining full control over the customer experience.

What is a marketplace operation?

A marketplace, on the other hand, is a platform where multiple sellers come together to offer their products or services to consumers. The marketplace operator doesn’t own the inventory but instead facilitates transactions between buyers and sellers. Well-known examples include Amazon, eBay, and Etsy.

The key characteristics of a marketplace include the following:

• Diverse product offerings: Marketplaces host a wide range of products from different sellers, offering consumers a larger selection.

• Facilitation role: The marketplace acts as a middleman, providing the infrastructure for sellers to engage with buyers.

• Revenue through commissions or fees: Marketplaces typically earn money through commissions on sales or subscription fees from sellers.

Marketplaces are ideal for businesses aiming to create a platform for diverse sellers and cater to a broader audience with a wide range of products or services.

Should you become an eCommerce platform or a marketplace?

Deciding between operating as an eCommerce platform or a marketplace involves carefully considering your business goals, resources, and the market you’re targeting. Each model comes with its own unique advantages.

Advantages of becoming a marketplace

Marketplaces come with a series of pros everyone should consider:

Larger product assortment 

By hosting multiple sellers, your marketplace can offer a wide variety of products without the need to manage or own inventory yourself. This expanded selection appeals to a broader audience and enhances the shopping experience, making your platform a one-stop shop for consumers. A larger assortment also encourages customers to return, knowing they can find almost anything they need all in one place. 

More control over the operation 

As the operator of the marketplace, you have the ability to define the rules, guidelines, and overall user experience. This control ensures that your platform maintains consistency, high quality, and a positive reputation. From setting seller standards to curating the look and feel of the interface, you shape how buyers and sellers interact, creating a seamless and trustworthy environment. 

More data and consumer insights 

Marketplaces generate a treasure trove of data from the activities of buyers and sellers. This data provides actionable insights into consumer behavior, market trends, and operational performance. By analyzing this information, you can optimize marketing strategies, refine user experiences, and make informed decisions to drive growth and profitability. 

Increased loyalty and reach for new customers 

A broad product selection and competitive pricing offered by marketplaces often lead to higher customer satisfaction and loyalty. When consumers know they can find what they’re looking for at great prices, they’re more likely to return. Additionally, marketplaces attract new customers seeking variety and convenience, helping you expand your reach and grow your user base. 

Improved regulation and mediation 

Marketplaces have the ability to implement systems and policies that ensure safe and fair transactions. By regulating seller practices, mediating disputes, and protecting buyer interests, your platform can foster a secure shopping environment. This not only builds trust among users but also enhances the long-term sustainability of your marketplace. 

While operating a marketplace provides substantial benefits, it also requires significant resources for technology, infrastructure, and managing multiple sellers.

Advantages of becoming an eCommerce platform

Becoming an eCommerce platform offers numerous opportunities for growth and revenue generation in the digital marketplace.

Network effects 

As your platform grows and attracts more users, the value of being part of the platform increases for everyone involved. Each new user adds more opportunities for interaction, creating a compounding effect that benefits both your business and your customers. Over time, this growth can significantly enhance customer loyalty and make your platform indispensable.

Facilitation of interactions 

An eCommerce platform allows you to connect directly with your customers, fostering real-time communication and support. This direct interaction helps you better understand their needs and preferences, building trust and loyalty while creating stronger, long-lasting relationships.

More value creation 

By selling your own products, you gain full control over pricing, branding, and the overall customer experience. This allows you to craft a unique value proposition that sets you apart from competitors, while also maximizing the potential for profit and brand recognition.

Better scalability 

An eCommerce platform provides the flexibility to grow your business at your own pace. You can expand product offerings, reach new markets, or increase your customer base without the added complexity and costs of relying on third-party sellers. This makes it easier to adapt to demand and scale efficiently.

Governance 

Running your own eCommerce platform gives you full control over every aspect of your operations. From setting customer service standards to managing shipping policies, you can ensure that every detail aligns with your brand’s values and goals. This level of control allows you to maintain the highest quality and consistency across the board.

An eCommerce platform is particularly advantageous for businesses that want to focus on growing their brand and building long-term relationships with customers.

Conclusion

Choosing between an eCommerce platform and a marketplace depends on your business goals, resources, and desired level of control. If you want to build your own brand, maintain customer relationships, and have full control over operations, an eCommerce platform may be the right choice. However, if you’re looking for a scalable model with diverse offerings and a built-in customer base, a marketplace could be the better option.

Both models have their strengths and challenges, and understanding these will help you make an informed decision about aligning your business with the right approach. Whichever path you choose, the key to success lies in delivering value to your customers and creating a seamless shopping experience.

Looking for an eCommerce agency to help you get your business on its feet (or scale up)? Contact Mayple and we'll match you with the best vetted agency for your specific needs, in less than 72 hours -- and we'll make sure we're there for you throughout the entire collaboration, ensuring you get the best results. No minimums, and you can cancel any time.

Mayple: Expert hires, proven success

Sign up now